David Robinson (8.22) vs Elgin Baylor (7.95) in Goatingo's all-time Basketball GOAT ranking. Compare scores, ratings and stats head to head.
On Goatingo's current Basketball GOAT ratings, David Robinson is ranked #22 with a score of 8.22 and Elgin Baylor is ranked #24 with 7.95. That is a gap of 0.28 points - a clear but narrow edge for David Robinson.
Every score combines an expert-built baseline with the average rating from the Goatingo community, so it moves as more fans vote. Open the comparison to see the scores, public votes and stats side by side, then add your own rating.
David Robinson · Elgin Baylor · Basketball GOAT ranking